Why Tesla Model X is the Best Choice Over the BMW X5 for Your Family
When deciding between two premium SUVs like the Tesla Model X and the BMW X5, it's important to break down the dimensions, performance, usability, and overall value. Both of these luxury SUVs offer impressive features, but they appeal to different types of drivers. This review will help you compare the Tesla Model X dimensions vs. the BMW X5 in detail to decide which one suits your needs.
Each vehicle has its advantages, but they are not perfect. Whether you're concerned about space, technology, or efficiency, knowing the details can make all the difference.
Tesla Model X vs BMW X5: An Overview
Both of these vehicles are popular choices in the luxury SUV market, but they cater to different preferences. While the BMW X5 represents traditional luxury with high-end materials and performance, the Tesla Model X stands out for its futuristic electric powertrain and high-tech features. Let's see what each one offers:
Tesla Model X Dimensions
The Tesla Model X is all-electric and boasts a design that feels futuristic inside and out. It's known for its signature Falcon Wing doors and massive glass roof, which creates a more open-feeling interior. When you look at the dimensions of the Model X, you'll notice it emphasizes space and height, making it a great choice for large families or those who prioritize cargo space.
Key Dimensions for Tesla Model X
- Length: 198.3 inches
- Width: 78.7 inches (without mirrors)
- Height: 66 inches
- Wheelbase: 116.7 inches
- Cargo Volume: Up to 88 cubic feet with seats down
- Seating Capacity: 5 to 7 passengers
The Tesla Model X's spacious interior is perfect for families who need lots of space for passengers and luggage. The rear Falcon Wing doors also make it easier to load kids or gear into the back seats, something that many SUV owners with children will appreciate.
However, it’s not all perfect. Alex Collantes, an automotive expert, mentions, “The Falcon Wing doors are cool, but they can be tricky in tight spaces. If you park in a cramped garage, you’ll need to be careful when opening them.” So while the doors are innovative, they may not be the best for urban environments where parking space is limited.
BMW X5 Dimensions
The BMW X5 on the other hand is a more traditional SUV. It offers a solid blend of luxury, performance, and comfort with its high-end finishes and German engineering excellence. While it may not have the futuristic flair of the Tesla Model X, the X5 holds its own as a powerful vehicle with internal combustion engine (ICE) and hybrid powertrains.
Key Dimensions for BMW X5
- Length: 194.3 inches
- Width: 78.9 inches (without mirrors)
- Height: 68.7 inches
- Wheelbase: 117.1 inches
- Cargo Volume: 72.3 cubic feet with seats down
- Seating Capacity: 5 to 7 passengers (with optional third row)
The BMW X5 might feel a bit more compact compared to the Tesla Model X, but it’s still roomy enough for most families. Its longer height gives it a more dominating presence on the road and better headroom inside, which can be an advantage for taller passengers.
However, the BMW X5 isn’t without its downsides either. According to Alex Collantes, “While the X5’s third-row seating option is nice, it’s really tight back there. If you’re planning to regularly carry seven passengers, the space is a bit of a squeeze compared to the Model X.” For those planning to use the third row regularly, this could be a drawback.
Interior Space: Practicality vs Luxury
When comparing interior space and practicality between the Tesla Model X and the BMW X5, each has its strengths and weaknesses. The Tesla feels bigger inside, thanks to its design and panoramic roof, while the BMW X5 focuses more on providing a classic luxury feel.
Tesla Model X: Maximum Usability
The Tesla Model X wins when it comes to versatility and space. The third-row seating is standard in the 6- and 7-seat configurations, and even with all the seats up, you still have a respectable amount of cargo room. The seats fold flat to give you a massive amount of storage space when you need it.
Additionally, the front trunk (frunk) provides extra storage space, which is something the BMW X5 can’t match because it has an engine up front.
But practicality isn't everything. Tesla’s minimalist interior can feel a bit too sparse for some buyers. The touchscreen-centered controls require you to do almost everything through a large display, which isn’t always ideal when you’re on the move. Some drivers have found it distracting.
BMW X5: Luxury First
The BMW X5 interior focuses on luxury and comfort. High-quality materials and thoughtful design elements abound. From the stitching on the leather seats to the feel of the steering wheel, everything feels top-notch.
But the luxury does come at a cost: the X5 doesn’t offer as much interior space as the Model X, and the cargo room with all seats in place is significantly smaller. The optional third row is quite cramped, and you’ll lose even more cargo space when it’s in use.
Alex Collantes mentions, “If you value luxury over pure practicality, the X5 wins hands down. But if you need to haul a lot of gear or use that third row often, you might feel a bit confined.”
Powertrain: Electric vs Traditional
This is where the Tesla Model X and BMW X5 diverge the most. The Tesla Model X is a fully electric SUV while the BMW X5 offers gasoline, diesel, and plug-in hybrid variants.
Tesla Model X: The Power of Electric
The Tesla Model X is powered by dual electric motors that provide instant torque and impressive acceleration. The Plaid version can reach 0-60 mph in just 2.5 seconds, which is mind-blowing for an SUV.
Electric Range: The Model X has a range of up to 348 miles depending on the configuration, making it one of the longest-range electric SUVs on the market.
However, charging infrastructure can still be a concern for some buyers. While Tesla’s Supercharger network is widespread and growing, those who often travel long distances in rural areas may find it limiting. The charging time is also longer compared to refueling a traditional gas-powered vehicle.
BMW X5: Traditional Power and Hybrid Options
The BMW X5 offers multiple powertrain options:
- Gasoline engines: Up to 523 horsepower in the X5 M50i version
- Plug-in hybrid (xDrive45e): Can drive up to 30 miles on electric power alone
- Diesel engines in certain markets
While the X5’s hybrid option is appealing for those who want to reduce their carbon footprint, it doesn’t match the Tesla Model X in terms of range or environmental benefits. And the fully gas-powered versions, while powerful, have worse fuel efficiency than the Tesla.
According to Alex Collantes, “If you’re not ready to go full electric yet but still want to reduce emissions, the BMW X5 hybrid is a great option. It gives you the flexibility to drive electric in the city and use gas for longer trips. But you won’t get anywhere near the same range as the Tesla Model X.”
Tech Features: Autopilot vs BMW iDrive
When it comes to tech, both vehicles offer cutting-edge technology, but the Tesla Model X pushes boundaries in ways the BMW X5 doesn’t quite reach.
Tesla Model X: Full Autopilot
Tesla’s Autopilot and Full Self-Driving (FSD) features are well-known, and they keep improving with software updates. The ability to handle highway driving, lane changes, and even parking makes Tesla the leader in autonomous driving technology.
However, many people still feel that FSD is not fully there yet, and regulations make it difficult to use to its fullest potential. Tesla’s updates are also reliant on the company’s own ecosystem, meaning certain features can be buggy until they’re ironed out in future updates.
BMW X5: Advanced but Traditional
BMW’s iDrive system is more traditional but very intuitive. It includes voice commands, gesture controls, and a well-designed infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. While the X5 doesn’t offer full autonomy, its driver-assist features are still very advanced and useful for everyday driving.
Price Comparison: Does It All Add Up?
The Tesla Model X is generally more expensive than the BMW X5, especially if you go for the Plaid model or add Full Self-Driving capability. However, you have to factor in fuel savings and lower maintenance costs with the Tesla.
The BMW X5 starts at a lower price but can get expensive quickly if you start adding options like the plug-in hybrid powertrain or the M50i trim.
Tesla Model X Pricing
- Base Price: Starting around $98,490
- Plaid Version: Upwards of $110,000
BMW X5 Pricing
- Base Price: Starting around $65,700
- M50i: Starting around $89,300
- Plug-in Hybrid: Around $72,500
While the BMW X5 is more affordable upfront, the long-term savings of the Tesla Model X might make up for the difference, especially for those committed to going electric.
Conclusion: Tesla Model X or BMW X5?
In the end the Tesla Model X is perfect for those who value innovation, electric power, and cutting-edge technology. If you need an SUV that offers the most space, longest range, and the most advanced features on the market, it’s hard to beat. However, its quirks like the Falcon Wing doors and reliance on touchscreen controls may not appeal to everyone.
The BMW X5, on the other hand, is an excellent option if you prefer luxury, traditional performance, and the flexibility of hybrid options. The iDrive system is intuitive, and the interior quality is top-notch, but its smaller third row and less cargo space could be limitations for larger families.
Alex Collantes sums it up well: “If you’re looking for the most forward-thinking SUV, the Model X is the way to go. But if you’re someone who wants a bit more tradition and comfort, the X5 won’t disappoint.”
Choose the Model that Best Suits Your Needs