MB GLA vs BMW X1: Which Compact Luxury SUV Should You Choose?

The compact luxury SUV market has been on fire lately with big players like Mercedes-Benz and BMW constantly refining their offerings. Two models that often face off head-to-head are the 2024 Mercedes-Benz GLA and the 2024 BMW X1. Both are stylish highly capable and packed with premium features but they have different personalities. In this article we will break down how these two competitors stack up against each other. We’ll cover everything from design performance features pricing and even what could be better about both to help you make the best decision.

Design and Exterior Styling

When you look at the 2024 Mercedes-Benz GLA and the BMW X1 one thing is clear – both of these luxury SUVs exude a premium vibe. But there are some differences in how each one approaches design.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Design

The GLA continues to carry Mercedes’ signature sleek and elegant aesthetic. Its rounded edges bold grille and sporty lines give it a polished look. While the GLA is an SUV its lower stance and coupe-like silhouette make it feel sporty and dynamic.

If you’re a fan of more fluid elegant designs the GLA might catch your eye first. The front grille with the three-pointed star makes a bold statement. It’s unmistakably a Mercedes-Benz from every angle. The GLA also offers LED lighting front and rear with a modern and distinctive signature.

However some drivers might find that the GLA looks a bit too much like a hatchback. While that’s not a bad thing for everyone some SUV enthusiasts might want something boxier and more rugged.

BMW X1 Design

On the other hand the 2024 BMW X1 offers a muscular and sporty design. BMW has made some updates to the X1’s appearance for 2024 giving it a slightly more angular and aggressive profile. The kidney grille has grown larger and the sharper lines running through the body give it a more athletic stance. The X1 looks like it means business with its upright shape and more SUV-like proportions.

Compared to the GLA the BMW X1 feels a bit more rugged and utilitarian. It looks more like a classic SUV which might appeal to drivers who prefer a more traditional approach to design.

But the downside here is that the X1’s chunky profile could look a bit less sophisticated compared to the GLA’s sleek styling. Some might say it leans more towards function than fashion.

Exterior Dimensions

Here’s how the MB GLA and BMW X1 compare in terms of size:

• GLA: 174.6 inches long 71.2 inches wide 63.5 inches tall
• X1: 177.2 inches long 72.6 inches wide 64.6 inches tall

While the X1 is a little bigger overall you won’t notice a huge difference in day-to-day driving.

Interior and Cabin Space

The interior experience is where luxury SUVs like the GLA and X1 truly differentiate themselves. Both offer high-quality materials modern technology and plenty of comfort features. But there are some key differences in the design and layout of each cabin.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Interior

Step inside the Mercedes GLA and you’re greeted by a modern tech-savvy interior. The dashboard is dominated by two large screens one for the digital gauge cluster and the other for the infotainment system. Mercedes’ MBUX system is a standout here allowing you to control most of the car’s functions with voice commands or through the touchscreen.

The materials inside the GLA are top-notch with plenty of soft-touch surfaces and leather upholstery on higher trims. There’s a sense of elegance throughout the cabin though it can feel a bit busy for some with all the tech and touch-sensitive controls.

One drawback in the GLA is the rear-seat space. It’s a bit tighter in the back compared to the X1. Taller passengers might find the headroom and legroom a little cramped.

BMW X1 Interior

The 2024 BMW X1 takes a more driver-focused approach. The dashboard is slightly angled toward the driver giving you easy access to all the controls. The X1’s new iDrive 8 infotainment system is sleek and easy to use with a combination of a rotary controller and touchscreen options.

The materials are equally luxurious but BMW tends to focus more on simplicity. You won’t find as many flashy screens or as many high-tech gimmicks. But that might be a good thing if you prefer minimalism in your cabin.

One area where the X1 excels is interior space. The X1 offers more rear-seat legroom and a roomier overall cabin. It feels a bit more spacious especially in the backseat where adult passengers can ride in more comfort.

Cargo Space

Cargo space is another area where the BMW X1 has a slight edge. Here’s how they compare:

• GLA Cargo Space: 15.4 cubic feet behind the second row
• X1 Cargo Space: 25.7 cubic feet behind the second row

If you’re planning to use your SUV for hauling groceries luggage or gear the X1 definitely offers more practicality.

Performance and Engine Options

Performance is a major consideration for many when choosing between these two SUVs. While both models offer a blend of efficiency and power there are some key differences in how each vehicle handles and performs.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Performance

The 2024 Mercedes GLA comes with a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 engine that produces 221 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque. It’s paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission and either front-wheel drive or 4MATIC all-wheel drive.

The GLA is quick off the line and feels agile around corners. Mercedes has done a great job making this small SUV feel sporty and fun to drive. However the steering can feel a bit light for those who want a more connected driving experience.

Fuel efficiency is a strong point for the GLA with up to 25 mpg in the city and 34 mpg on the highway.

BMW X1 Performance

The 2024 BMW X1 also comes with a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 but it produces a bit more power at 241 horsepower and 295 lb-ft of torque. It’s mated to a 7-speed dual-clutch automatic and comes standard with xDrive all-wheel drive.

When it comes to driving dynamics the X1 feels more athletic than the GLA. The steering is more responsive and you get a better sense of control especially when cornering. The dual-clutch transmission also makes the X1 feel quicker and more engaging to drive.

Fuel economy for the X1 is slightly lower at 23 mpg in the city and 31 mpg on the highway but the extra performance might be worth it for some drivers.

Technology and Features

Both the GLA and X1 are loaded with technology and features that make driving easier and more enjoyable. From advanced infotainment systems to driver-assistance features there’s plenty to love about both SUVs.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Technology

The Mercedes-Benz User Experience (MBUX) system is one of the most advanced in the industry. It features a 10.25-inch touchscreen and another 10.25-inch digital instrument cluster. The system supports voice commands so you can simply say “Hey Mercedes” to adjust settings or get information.

The GLA also comes with plenty of standard features including:

• Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
• Dual-zone climate control
• Adaptive cruise control

However the sheer number of touch-sensitive controls and screens can be overwhelming for some. It takes time to get used to all the tech in the GLA. Alex Collantes a tech-savvy SUV enthusiast notes "While I love how advanced the MBUX is it feels like you're living in a tech bubble which might not be for everyone".

BMW X1 Technology

The BMW iDrive 8 system is equally impressive but it takes a more intuitive approach. The 10.7-inch central display and digital gauge cluster are crisp and clear. You can control the system with the rotary dial or via the touchscreen. Some might prefer this setup because it offers a bit more physical control compared to the MBUX system.

The X1 also comes standard with:

• Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
• Heated front seats
• Adaptive cruise control

One downside is that the X1’s infotainment system can feel a bit dated compared to the GLA’s more futuristic setup. While it works great some users might miss the flashier features of the MBUX system.

Safety and Driver Assistance Features

Both the GLA and X1 offer plenty of safety features but the exact options and availability vary depending on the trim level.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Safety Features

The 2024 GLA comes with a suite of standard safety features including:

• Forward-collision warning
• Automatic emergency braking
• Blind-spot monitoring

There are also a number of optional features like adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assist. Mercedes’ driver-assistance tech is highly regarded for its accuracy but it can feel a little intrusive at times.

BMW X1 Safety Features

The 2024 X1 is also well-equipped with standard safety features like:

• Automatic emergency braking
• Lane-departure warning
• Blind-spot monitoring

BMW’s Driving Assistance Package adds features like adaptive cruise control and traffic jam assist. The system is smooth and intuitive and doesn’t feel too aggressive compared to some of Mercedes’ systems.

Pricing and Value

Pricing is always a big factor when choosing between two luxury SUVs. Here’s a breakdown of the pricing for the 2024 Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X1.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Pricing

The 2024 GLA starts at around $39,000 for the base GLA 250. Opting for 4MATIC all-wheel drive will add a few thousand dollars to the price.

Higher trims and more features can push the price up into the mid-$40,000 range. While the GLA is competitively priced you can quickly rack up costs with optional packages and upgrades.

BMW X1 Pricing

The 2024 BMW X1 starts at around $40,500. While the base price is slightly higher than the GLA the X1 comes with standard all-wheel drive which is a big plus.

Fully loaded models can reach $47,000 or more but the X1 offers a bit more standard equipment at its base price.

Potential Drawbacks

While both the GLA and X1 are fantastic vehicles they aren’t without their downsides. Here’s a quick summary of what could be better about each.

Mercedes-Benz GLA Drawbacks

• Tight rear-seat space for taller passengers
• Overwhelming technology interface for some users
• Less cargo space compared to the BMW X1

BMW X1 Drawbacks

• Less flashy infotainment system compared to MBUX
• Higher starting price (though all-wheel drive is included)
• Some might find the design a bit too rugged for a luxury SUV

Final Thoughts: Which One is Right for You?

At the end of the day choosing between the 2024 Mercedes-Benz GLA and the BMW X1 comes down to your personal preferences.

If you value sleek design cutting-edge tech and want the prestige of the Mercedes-Benz badge the GLA is an excellent choice. Just be prepared to compromise on rear-seat space and cargo room.

On the other hand if you prefer a sporty driving experience more interior space and a slightly more rugged SUV vibe the BMW X1 is likely a better fit. The X1 offers more practicality but its infotainment system might not wow you like the MBUX.

Whichever you choose both vehicles are sure to impress with their luxury quality and performance. You really can’t go wrong but one will likely match your lifestyle better than the other.