5 Reasons Why the Hyundai Tucson Beats the Subaru Forester – And 3 Reasons it Doesn’t
When it comes to compact SUVs the Hyundai Tucson and the Subaru Forester are perennial favorites for drivers seeking reliable performance family-friendly comfort and that sweet mix of utility and style. But which one takes the crown for 2024? If you're in the market for one of these capable crossovers or just love a good old head-to-head showdown buckle up. Let's break down how these two vehicles stack up against each other in terms of performance interior tech safety features and everything in between.
Overview: Two Popular SUVs with Different Personalities
The Hyundai Tucson has become a stylish contender in the compact SUV segment with an impressive modern design and a host of technological upgrades for the new model year. Hyundai's goal? Deliver a car that's as great to drive as it is to look at.
The Subaru Forester on the other hand is the rugged outdoorsy cousin who's always ready for an adventure. It has a loyal following among those who prioritize all-wheel-drive capability and practical interior space. For those who think hiking boots are formal wear – the Forester has always been a solid pick.
1. Design & Exterior: Hyundai Tucson’s Modern Edge vs. Subaru Forester’s Rugged Simplicity
Hyundai Tucson
One thing is clear – the Tucson has style for days. With its parametric grille, bold LED lighting, and chiseled lines it looks more like a crossover concept car that somehow got the green light for production. The latest model got a bit of a "glow-up," and it’s noticeable from every angle. From the front to the taillights it screams modern sophistication.
- Pros: Sleek futuristic design with an urban edge
- Cons: Some might find it too flashy for an SUV in this class – like it’s trying to win "best dressed" at prom
Subaru Forester
The Forester? Well it’s not trying to be something it’s not. Subaru keeps things simple and practical with a boxy design that's all about function over form. It’s not winning any beauty contests but that means more vertical space inside and a focus on durability over dazzle.
- Pros: Rugged look with a practical design focus; won’t mind getting a little mud on the tires
- Cons: Styling is a bit “meh” – if the Forester were a pair of shoes they’d be a sensible pair of sneakers rather than designer loafers
2. Engine & Performance: Power Meets Efficiency
When it comes to what's under the hood the Tucson and Forester have their own unique approaches to performance.
Hyundai Tucson
The Tucson offers multiple powertrains including a 2.5L inline-4 engine plus hybrid and plug-in hybrid options for the eco-conscious. The standard engine has 187 hp which gives it a little more pep than the Forester. Plus with the hybrid versions you're looking at excellent fuel economy.
- Pros: Multiple engine options; better fuel efficiency with hybrid versions
- Cons: The base engine is not exactly thrilling – it’s like ordering the "mild" salsa when you really wanted "spicy"
Subaru Forester
The Forester sticks to what it knows best – a 2.5L flat-four "Boxer" engine that generates 182 hp. The symmetrical all-wheel drive gives the Forester its legendary handling capabilities especially on off-road terrain or slippery surfaces. It’s not winning any races but it's a trusty workhorse.
- Pros: Standard all-wheel drive; solid handling especially for those weekend trips off the beaten path
- Cons: Only one engine option and it’s not going to set your heart racing – more of a “slow and steady wins the race” approach
3. Interior & Comfort: Spacious vs. Tech-Savvy
Hyundai Tucson
Inside the Tucson you're treated to a refined cabin with high-quality materials. Hyundai has packed it with features like a 10.25-inch touchscreen infotainment system wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto and available heated and ventilated seats. It’s all about making the drive as comfortable and connected as possible.
- Pros: High-end tech features; premium materials and plenty of creature comforts
- Cons: The touchscreen controls can be a bit distracting – at some point we all miss the simplicity of a good ol’ button
Subaru Forester
In contrast the Forester takes a more practical approach. Spacious is the name of the game here with ample headroom and legroom for all passengers plus a cargo area that’ll fit anything from groceries to camping gear. Subaru's interiors have come a long way but it still keeps a "back-to-basics" vibe in comparison to the Tucson.
- Pros: Spacious cabin; straightforward controls; excellent visibility
- Cons: Interior design might feel a little dated for those who want more tech pizzazz
4. Safety & Driver-Assistance: Both Play It Safe (In a Good Way)
Both the Tucson and Forester score high in safety – so no worries there.
Hyundai Tucson Safety
Hyundai’s SmartSense safety suite comes standard and includes features like Forward Collision-Avoidance Assist Lane Keeping Assist Driver Attention Warning and more. The Tucson has also earned high safety ratings from the IIHS and NHTSA.
- Pros: Comprehensive safety features and driver assistance come standard
- Cons: Adaptive cruise control is a little too "nervous" for some drivers – braking at the slightest hint of a shadow
Subaru Forester Safety
Subaru is well-known for its commitment to safety with EyeSight Driver Assist Technology standard across all trims. This includes Pre-Collision Braking Adaptive Cruise Control Lane Departure Warning and more. It also boasts a strong safety structure making it a reliable choice.
- Pros: Standard EyeSight suite; strong safety structure
- Cons: The driver-assist beeps and warnings can feel like a nagging backseat driver at times – “Hey Forester I got it I’m paying attention!”
5. Pricing & Trims: Where’s Your Sweet Spot?
Both SUVs come with a range of trims but let's break down the basics.
Hyundai Tucson
The Tucson has a base price starting around $27,000 and goes up to over $37,000 for the top trim Limited AWD Hybrid. For what you get that’s pretty good value especially considering the tech and safety features included across trims.
- Pros: Good price-to-features ratio; wide range of trims
- Cons: Add on those extras and suddenly your budget SUV is pushing luxury prices
Subaru Forester
The Forester starts at a similar price point around $26,500 and goes up to about $36,000 for the Touring trim. Even the base model comes standard with all-wheel drive and many safety features which makes it a value play for those looking for capability and peace of mind.
- Pros: Standard all-wheel drive; good value with plenty of included features
- Cons: Limited engine options and fewer tech upgrades might leave some drivers wanting more
The Verdict: Tucson vs Forester – Which One's for You?
If you want style and tech the Hyundai Tucson is your go-to with its modern design multiple powertrain options and plush interior features. It’s perfect for those who drive more around the city and want a connected comfortable experience.
On the flip side if you're all about reliability practicality and outdoor capability the Subaru Forester is tough to beat. With its standard all-wheel drive and roomy interior it's ideal for those who love the great outdoors or just need that extra space for a busy lifestyle.
What Alex Collantes Thinks
“Both the Hyundai Tucson and Subaru Forester are excellent choices but for me it boils down to what you're looking for in a vehicle. If you’re tech-savvy and want something that feels fresh and new the Tucson is your pick. But if you’re more into capability over looks and appreciate a good dependable SUV then the Forester's got you covered," says Alex Collantes, a long-time auto enthusiast and weekend adventurer.
Pros & Cons – At a Glance
Hyundai Tucson Pros:
- Modern stylish design
- Multiple powertrains including hybrid
- High-quality interior materials
Hyundai Tucson Cons:
- Touchscreen controls can be distracting
- Base engine is a bit underwhelming
- Add-on options can get pricey
Subaru Forester Pros:
- Standard all-wheel drive
- Spacious and practical interior
- Strong safety features
Subaru Forester Cons:
- Styling is conservative
- Limited engine options
- Safety beeps might drive you a little bonkers
Key Takeaways: Finding the Right Fit
- Choose the Hyundai Tucson if you value tech features and a stylish design.
- Choose the Subaru Forester if you need all-wheel drive and more interior space.
- Tucson offers better fuel economy with its hybrid option.
- Forester has better off-road capability with standard all-wheel drive.
- Pricing is similar but add-ons can push the Tucson into a more premium bracket.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day choosing between the Hyundai Tucson and Subaru Forester comes down to your personal preferences. Want a refined tech-savvy ride? The Tucson will check those boxes. Prefer a practical and rugged vehicle that can take you anywhere? The Forester has you covered. Each SUV has its strengths and weaknesses but both are solid choices in the ever-growing compact SUV market.
Whichever you choose you’re guaranteed a dependable ride that’ll handle both the daily commute and those spontaneous weekend getaways.
Drive safe – and enjoy the journey!
Sources and References
- Official Hyundai USA website (2024 Tucson Specs & Features)
- Official Subaru USA website (2024 Forester Specs & Features)
- IIHS and NHTSA safety ratings for both vehicles
- Consumer Reports & J.D. Power reviews for owner feedback