BMW X5 vs Volvo XC90: Which Luxury SUV is Right for You?
When you're in the market for a luxury SUV, two names are bound to pop up more often than not: BMW X5 and Volvo XC90. Both models are premium offerings from top automakers, and they come with a lot of tech, luxury, and performance features. But which one is right for you? In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll dive into both vehicles—looking at performance, safety, design, technology, and overall value—to help you make an informed decision.
Overview of BMW X5 and Volvo XC90
Both the BMW X5 and the Volvo XC90 are well-established names in the luxury SUV segment. The X5, representing BMW’s trademark “Ultimate Driving Machine” slogan, offers an impressive balance of power and agility while the XC90 is more focused on providing comfort, safety, and a modern Scandinavian design.
BMW X5
The BMW X5 is now in its fourth generation, with the latest model first hitting the road in 2018 and continuously updated. It’s available with a range of powerful engines and includes a plug-in hybrid model (BMW X5 xDrive45e), known for its stellar combination of performance and fuel efficiency.
Volvo XC90
Volvo's flagship SUV, the XC90, has been around since 2002, with the second generation launching in 2015. Volvo is known for its focus on safety, and the XC90 showcases this commitment with a range of advanced driver assistance features. Like the X5, the XC90 is also available as a plug-in hybrid (XC90 Recharge).
Performance and Engine Options
Performance is a big factor for anyone looking at luxury SUVs. While both the BMW X5 and Volvo XC90 offer a comfortable ride, they differ significantly in engine performance and overall driving dynamics.
BMW X5 Performance
The BMW X5 offers a wider range of powertrains, from a turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six to a high-performance twin-turbocharged V8. Here's a breakdown of available engine options:
- 3.0L turbocharged inline-six (335 hp): The base engine provides a smooth balance of power and efficiency.
- 4.4L twin-turbo V8 (523 hp): The high-performance engine available in the X5 M50i offers thrilling speed and dynamic handling.
- Plug-in hybrid xDrive45e: The hybrid system combines the inline-six engine with an electric motor to produce 389 hp, offering a nice blend of efficiency and performance. It also offers an all-electric range of about 30 miles, perfect for city driving.
In terms of handling, the X5 offers excellent agility for an SUV, especially with the available adaptive M suspension. The xDrive all-wheel-drive system ensures that the vehicle remains planted, even on twisty roads. BMW's sporty DNA really shines through, and it offers a more engaging driving experience than the XC90.
Drawbacks of the BMW X5's performance can include:
- The V8 models come with significantly higher fuel consumption.
- Some may find the ride a bit stiff compared to the more comfort-oriented XC90.
Volvo XC90 Performance
The Volvo XC90 leans towards a calm, composed driving experience. It's not as performance-focused as the X5 but excels in providing a smooth and comfortable ride. Here's what you get under the hood:
- 2.0L four-cylinder engine (250 hp): Found in the base T5 model, this engine is sufficient for daily driving but lacks the power some buyers might want.
- 2.0L turbo- and supercharged four-cylinder (316 hp): The T6 model offers more power and a sportier feel without sacrificing too much on fuel economy.
- Plug-in hybrid T8 (455 hp): The XC90 Recharge combines a turbocharged and supercharged 2.0-liter engine with an electric motor, providing excellent efficiency and a decent 18-mile electric range.
Where the XC90 excels is in its ride quality. It's more comfortable than the X5 over bumps and rough roads. However, if you prioritize driving dynamics and enjoy a more engaged driving experience, the XC90 might not excite you as much.
Potential drawbacks for the Volvo XC90's performance:
- The T5 engine feels underpowered when the vehicle is fully loaded.
- The plug-in hybrid's electric range is less than the X5 xDrive45e.
Interior and Comfort
Both the BMW X5 and Volvo XC90 are premium SUVs, but their interior designs reflect different philosophies. The BMW X5 goes for a sportier, driver-focused cabin, while the Volvo XC90 embraces Scandinavian minimalism and elegance.
BMW X5 Interior
The BMW X5 features a luxurious cabin with high-quality materials and advanced technology. The dashboard is dominated by a 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster and a matching infotainment display. BMW's iDrive system is one of the best in the business, offering easy navigation and crisp graphics.
Key interior features:
- Premium leather upholstery
- Heated front seats (with optional ventilation and massaging functions)
- Panoramic sunroof
- Optional third-row seating
The X5 offers plenty of space for passengers in the first and second rows. However, the optional third row is a bit cramped, making it suitable only for children.
One downside of the BMW X5's interior is that some of the more desirable features (like massaging seats and premium sound systems) require you to opt for pricey packages or higher trims.
Volvo XC90 Interior
Volvo has nailed the interior design with the XC90. It's simple yet elegant, with a focus on natural materials like open-pore wood and soft-touch leather. The center stack is dominated by a 9-inch portrait-oriented touchscreen, which controls most of the vehicle's functions. This design keeps the dashboard free of clutter, contributing to a serene atmosphere.
Key interior features:
- Nappa leather upholstery
- Heated and ventilated front seats
- Bowers & Wilkins premium sound system (optional)
- Third-row seating (standard in most trims)
The third row in the XC90 is more spacious than the X5’s, making it more practical for families. Plus, the XC90 offers a cleaner, airier cabin with its large windows and panoramic sunroof. The attention to detail is impressive, but the touchscreen controls for basic functions (like climate control) can be a bit fiddly and might take some getting used to.
Drawbacks for the Volvo XC90's interior include:
- The infotainment system can be slow at times.
- Some users report that the seat padding is a bit firm for long drives.
Technology and Infotainment
Both SUVs are packed with cutting-edge technology. However, the way the tech is implemented varies significantly between the two.
BMW X5 Technology
BMW's iDrive 7 system is one of the most intuitive infotainment systems on the market. You can control it via a rotary dial, the touchscreen, or even voice commands. The system is responsive, with a clear interface, and supports Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Notable tech features:
- 12.3-inch infotainment screen
- Gesture control (optional)
- Wireless smartphone charging
- Harman Kardon sound system (standard on higher trims)
The gesture controls in the X5 are a unique feature, though some might find them more of a gimmick than a practical tool.
Volvo XC90 Technology
The XC90 uses a portrait-oriented touchscreen that runs Volvo's Sensus Connect infotainment system. It looks great, but the touchscreen-based control of nearly everything can sometimes be a bit finicky. That said, it still offers Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and navigation.
Notable tech features:
- 9-inch touchscreen display
- Head-up display (available in higher trims)
- Bowers & Wilkins audio system (optional)
The XC90’s voice control system works well for basic commands, but the learning curve for the touchscreen system might take some getting used to.
Safety and Driver Assistance
Volvo has built its reputation on safety. The XC90 is packed with advanced safety tech and has received high marks in crash tests. However, the BMW X5 also comes with a wide array of driver assistance features, so let’s compare.
BMW X5 Safety
BMW includes a decent suite of standard safety features, but most of the advanced systems are part of optional packages.
Key safety features include:
- Forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking
- Blind-spot monitoring
- Lane-departure warning
- Available adaptive cruise control with stop-and-go capability
- Available night vision (optional)
The adaptive cruise control works well on highways, and the lane-keeping assist is smooth and subtle, although some competitors offer more features as standard.
Volvo XC90 Safety
Volvo takes safety to the next level, and the XC90 comes standard with many of the features that are optional on the X5.
Key safety features include:
- Collision mitigation (with automatic braking)
- Blind-spot monitoring
- Lane-keeping assist
- Pilot Assist (adaptive cruise control with semi-autonomous driving capability)
- Run-off road protection
The Pilot Assist system allows the XC90 to handle some steering tasks on highways. Volvo’s commitment to safety shines through, making the XC90 an excellent choice for safety-conscious buyers.
Price and Value
When comparing the BMW X5 and Volvo XC90, price is always a factor. Both are premium SUVs, but they cater to slightly different buyer preferences.
BMW X5 Price
The BMW X5 starts at around $65,000, but the price can quickly climb if you add options like the plug-in hybrid powertrain or V8 engine. Higher trims like the X5 M50i can push the price well over $85,000.
Volvo XC90 Price
The Volvo XC90 starts at a slightly lower price point, around $57,000. Even the plug-in hybrid version starts at around $72,000, making it more affordable than the X5's equivalent.
The XC90’s lower starting price makes it a more attractive option for buyers who want a luxury SUV but aren’t as focused on high-performance.
Final Verdict: BMW X5 vs Volvo XC90
When it comes to choosing between the BMW X5 and Volvo XC90, it really depends on what you value most in an SUV.
If you prioritize performance and enjoy driving dynamics, the BMW X5 is hard to beat. It's a driver's SUV with strong engines and sharp handling. However, the price can escalate quickly, especially if you want a high-performance model or all the luxury bells and whistles.
On the other hand, if safety, comfort, and a serene driving experience are higher on your list, the Volvo XC90 is an excellent choice. It's more affordable, spacious, and loaded with standard safety features, making it a great option for families.
As Alex Collantes, a luxury SUV owner, puts it: "I went with the Volvo XC90 because of its focus on safety and design. While I appreciated the performance of the BMW X5, I found that the XC90 offered a smoother ride and better value for my money, especially with all the standard features."
To sum up:
- Choose the BMW X5 if you want performance, driving thrills, and a sporty cabin.
- Choose the Volvo XC90 if you value comfort, safety, and a more luxurious, relaxing interior.
Both SUVs are excellent in their own right but understanding your priorities will help you make the best choice.
FAQs
What is the fuel economy of the BMW X5 compared to the Volvo XC90?
The BMW X5 gets about 21-26 mpg combined depending on the model while the Volvo XC90 offers around 22-27 mpg depending on engine choice and trim.
Does the Volvo XC90 have more safety features than the BMW X5?
Yes the Volvo XC90 comes standard with more safety features than the BMW X5 which requires you to opt for additional packages to get similar levels of safety tech.
Which SUV is better for long road trips?
The Volvo XC90 with its softer ride and more spacious cabin is likely to be a better choice for long trips especially if you’re traveling with a full load of passengers.